Apple arrintan way ku khaldan tahay
Apple waa mid ka mid ah shirkadaha ugu waaweyn abid, waxayna sumcad ku dhisatay inay si weyn ugu fiirsato faahfaahinta ugu yar. Nasiib darro, dacwaddan taxaddar-darrada ah, gardarrada leh, isla markaana si aan caadi ahayn shakhsi u beegsanaysa, uma qalanto sumcaddaas.
Apple waxay sheegtay inay OpenAI la soo xidhiidhay bishii Febraayo, annaguna aannaan u jawaabin. Hadda waxay qirteen in qareennadooda dibaddu ay iimayl u direen qof khaldan, kaddib markii ay isku qaldeen laba magac-qoys oo Aasiyaan ah—waxayna qirteen keliya markii aannu arrintan u sheegnay. Apple waxay sidoo kale sheegtay inay wada hadal la yeelatay La-taliyahayaga Guud ee Sharciga, taas oo ay hadda qiratay inaanay weligeed dhicin. Hase yeeshee, waxay mar kale qarinayaan inaanay wakhtigaas soo qaadin eedaha gaarka ah ee dacwaddan ku jira, iyo inay dhab ahaantii noo sheegeen inay “xallinayeen wixii arrimo ah ee jiray”. Intaas kaddib, wax war ah kama aannu helin muddo shan bilood ah, ilaa ay dacwad nagu soo oogeen. Qoraalkeedii ugu dambeeyay, Apple waxay aad isugu dayaysaa inay si qalloocan u fasirto dhacdooyinkan, balse adiga ayaa iimayllada ka akhrisan kara halkan.
Apple waxay Chang Liu ku eedaynaysaa inuu helay macluumaad sir u ah Apple markii uu shirkadda ka tegay, balse hadda uun bay qiratay in shaqaalaha Apple ay la soo xidhiidheen oo ay ka codsadeen inuu ka caawiyo helidda macluumaadkan (farriimaha waxaad ka akhrisan kartaa halkan). Apple waxay hadda isku dayaysaa inay eedda u wareejiso “helitaanka hadhay”, balse sidoo kale ma sheegto in tani tahay dhibaato Apple ku badan oo ka dhalata inay si habboon u maamuli weydo helitaanka nidaamyada marka shaqaaluhu ka tagaan. Dhab ahaan, tani waxay ka dhigan tahay in shaqaalihii hore ee isku dayaya inay sida saxda ah wax u sameeyaan marka ay tagayaan ay weli heli karaan faylasha Apple—iyaga oo aan rabin ama xataa ka warqabin.
Apple waxay sidoo kale Tang Tan ku eedaynaysaa inuu isku dayay inuu helo oo isticmaalo sirteeda ganacsi. Hase yeeshee, Tang wuxuu mar walba kooxda si cad ugu sheegay inaannaan doonayn, isla markaana ay waajib tahay inaannaan isticmaalin, wax macluumaad sir ah oo shirkado kale leeyihiin. Tang wuxuu Apple u shaqeeyay in ka badan 24 sano, waxaana si weyn loogu yaqaannay inuu ahaa mid ka mid ah hoggaamiyeyaasha ugu hal-abuurka badan shirkadda.
Waxaannu jeclaan lahayn in Apple ay arrimahan nala wadaagto ka hor intaanay dacwadda gudbin; farxad ayaannu dhammaan arrimahan ugu caddayn lahayn. Eedaha dacwadda ku jira si dhab ah ayaannu u qaadannay, waxaanuna Apple u bandhignay inaannu kala shaqayno xallinta arrintan. Taa beddelkeeda, waxay isku dayayaan inay beddelaan sida ay dhacdada u sheegayaan, oo ay ku jiraan eedo aan caddayn oo ay u jeedinayaan shaqaale kale oo hore, waxayna u badan tahay inay xeeladdan sii wadaan.
Codsiga Apple ee amar maxkamadeed oo ku-meel-gaar ah wuxuu ku salaysan yahay macluumaad been ah, gebi ahaanna looma baahna, maadaama aannan hayn, doonaynna, wax sir ganacsi ah oo ay leeyihiin. Waxaannu aad u danaynaynaa dhisidda badeecooyin iyo teknoolajiyooyin hal-abuur leh oo gaadha heerka ugu casriyeysan.
Cusboonaysiin 6 Agoosto 2026: Codsigayaga laalista dacwadda waxaad ka akhrisan kartaa halkan(ku furmaa daaqad cusub).
Cusboonaysiin 1 Sebtembar 2026: Jawaabtayada diidmada codsiga Apple ee amarka maxkamadeed ee ku-meel-gaarka ah waxaad ka akhrisan kartaa halkan(ku furmaa daaqad cusub).
Cusboonaysiin 14 Sebtembar 2026: Jawaabtayada qoraalka dheeriga ah ee Apple waxaa laga heli karaa halkan(ku furmaa daaqad cusub).
Farriimo
iMessages dhex maray Chang Liu (oo buluug ku qoran) iyo shaqaalaha Apple, kuwaas oo saaxiibbadiisii hore ay Chang—oo maalintiisii ugu dambaysay ee Apple ahayd 22 Jannaayo 2026—ka codsanayaan inuu ka caawiyo helidda faylal iyo macluumaad ay ugu baahan yihiin shaqadooda Apple (wakhtiyada oo dhan waa UTC). Ogeysiis: magacyada dadka kale iyo macluumaadka sirta ah ee Apple waa la qariyey.


Waraaqaha iimaylka
Iimayllada soo socda waxay dhex mareen qareenka dibadda ee Apple, Gabriel Gross; La-taliyaha Guud ee Sharciga ee OpenAI, Che Chang; iyo la-taliyayaasha sharciga ee gudaha Apple. Waxay muujinayaan in Gross uu Che si khalad ah iimayl ugu diray, isla markaana uu si aan sax ahayn u sheegay inay wada hadleen. Gross iyo la-taliyayaasha sharciga ee gudaha Apple labaduba markii dambe waxay xaqiijiyeen inuu khalad dhacay, iyadoo Gross uu sheegay inay “xallinayeen wixii arrimo ah ee jiray”. Eedaha gaarka ah ee dacwadda Apple ku jira marnaba lama soo qaadin, wax xidhiidh dambe ahna ma dhicin ka hor intaan dacwadda la gudbin shan bilood kaddib.
Dear Mr. Chang:
Please see the attached letter and let me know when you are free to discuss it.
Yours,
Gabriel Gross Partner Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP <redacted> <redacted> <redacted> Direct <redacted> Mobile
The information contained in this email message is intended only for use of the individual or entity named above. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient, or the employee or agent responsible to deliver it to the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution or copying of this communication is strictly prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please immediately notify us by email, <redacted> and destroy the original message. Thank you.
Attachments:
- image001.jpg (6K)
- 2026.02.23 G. Gross letter to <redacted> Wang(101156327.1).pdf (225K)
- Ex. A.pdf (491K)
- Ex. B.pdf (91K)
- Ex. C.pdf (1646K)
Dear Mr. Chang:
Thank you for your phone call just now and for offering your cooperation so quickly. I will be back in touch after speaking with Apple. I realize I neglected to include the three attachments when I sent you my letter, so I am re-sending it with the attachments for your records.
Yours,
Gabe
Hi [Apple in-house legal counsel] and [Apple in-house legal counsel],
This guy from Weil claims to be representing you. For some reason, he is lying about speaking with me on the phone. I don't know who he is and we have never spoken.
I don't know what the point of his lie is, but could you please confirm if he is actually representing you, and if so, whether you have other counsel you can use. I don’t think interacting through him is appropriate given this behavior.
If this isn’t the right Apple team, could you let me know who might be? Thank you.
Che
Dear Mr. Chang:
I write to follow up on my email and letter from yesterday. After I emailed you around 5:53 p.m. yesterday, I inadvertently also sent you another email around 6:07 p.m. that was intended for <redacted> Wang, one of the former Apple employees at issue. After we had emailed Mr. Wang yesterday about retaining Apple information, he promptly called me and offered to cooperate with Apple in resolving any issues. I then intended to email him again, but accidentally replied to my email chain with you instead. I apologize for the confusion that likely caused.
Yours,
Gabriel Gross Partner Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP <redacted> <redacted> <redacted> Direct <redacted> Mobile
Gabe
Hi Che,
Wanted to make sure to get back to you. Weil is our counsel on this matter, and I believe they should have contacted you explaining the miscommunication. Please feel free to direct any additional questions their way.
Thanks,
[Apple in-house legal counsel]


